Sean Tissue
Insights  /  Construction Operations

Crews or Subs: Self-Perform vs Subcontract and When Vertical Integration Pays

In brief

Self-perform vs subcontract comes down to one number, the share of paid crew hours that produce finished, inspected work. With the illustrative rates below, an in-house crew beats a subcontractor only above a break-even utilization of 55 to 80 percent, and a Michigan winter alone can erase that margin. Keep steady, repeatable trades in house. Subcontract trades with peaks, licensing or specialty equipment, and price the risk of each choice into the bid.

Most guides on this question define the terms or explain tax classification. This one gives a formula you can run on your own payroll, uses federal wage data for the Detroit area, and covers the two Michigan exposures that change the math: the calendar and workers' compensation liability.

What does self-perform mean in construction?

Self-perform means a builder or general contractor uses its own employees to do a trade's work, such as framing, concrete or finish carpentry, instead of hiring a subcontractor for that scope. Doing this across many trades is a form of vertical integration in construction: the builder takes on work that others buy from outside firms. The benefit is control of schedule and quality. The cost is payroll that continues on days when there is no work.

What a crew hour really costs

The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics put the mean hourly wage for construction and extraction occupations in the Detroit area at $32.43 in May 2024.

Wages understate the cost. In the Bureau's June 2026 employer cost data, benefits and legally required costs add about 45 cents for every dollar of wages in construction and extraction occupations: $14.47 on top of $32.17. Applied to the Detroit wage, a crew hour costs about $47.

Add the lead's time, trucks, tools, small equipment and fuel. This post assumes ten percent for those items, which brings the figure to about $52. Your own books will give the real number.

Self-perform vs subcontract: the break-even formula

Break-even utilization = loaded crew cost per hour divided by the sub's all-in price per labor hour.

Utilization is productive hours divided by paid hours. Productive means installed work that passes inspection. Weather days, material waits, travel, rework and idle time are paid but not productive. For the sub's side, divide the scope price by the labor hours you estimate for the same work. The sub rates below are assumptions for illustration, not market quotes.

Sub price per labor hour Break-even at $47 crew cost Break-even at $52 crew cost
$65 72% 80%
$75 63% 69%
$85 55% 61%

If a sub prices a scope at the equivalent of $75 an hour and your loaded crew costs $52, the crew wins only when at least 69 percent of the hours you pay for produce finished work. Below that, the sub is cheaper even though the sub's hourly rate looks higher.

Why Michigan raises the break-even

A crew that has work eight months of the year but is paid for twelve is capped at 67 percent utilization before a single rain delay. Laying the crew off in January means recruiting every spring. The more work you can run under protection in winter, the more crew hours you can justify. The cold-weather schedule is in How to Keep a Michigan Construction Schedule Through Winter.

The risks that come with a subcontractor

A sub's price is not the whole price. Two Michigan exposures belong in the comparison.

Workers' compensation. Under MCL 418.171, if a principal contracts with a contractor who has not complied with the act, the principal is liable for the compensation owed to that contractor's workers as if they were its own employees. The statute treats subcontractors as contractors and lets the principal seek indemnity, but that claim is only as good as the sub's finances. Collect a current certificate of insurance before the first day and track its expiration through the job.

Trade licensing. Michigan exempts licensed electrical, plumbing and mechanical contractors from the residential builder license for their own trade work (MCL 339.2403). Those trades arrive with their own state licenses, so verify each one on the state lookup before signing.

What a crew buys that a price does not

A sub sells a scope and a date. A crew sells control. When the schedule is the constraint, as it is with many houses moving at once, control is worth money. In-house labor also gives faster answers on how a detail is built and what it costs, so a drawing problem gets fixed on Tuesday instead of negotiated as a change order on Friday. When the same house is built many times, the crew learns it and rework drops. That is the production logic behind How to Run a Build-to-Rent Project From Land to Lease-Up.

A mixed model with rules

I ran in-house crews alongside a project management team directing subcontractors. Each trade had to earn its place in house on the numbers.

  • Keep in house work that exists on every project, every week it runs: rough carpentry, trim, punch and closeout.
  • Subcontract anything with a license barrier, a seasonal peak, or a machine you would own for a few weeks a year.
  • Test the split every quarter with the formula. If a crew's utilization sits under its break-even for two quarters, change the scope or the headcount.
  • Bid the sub's risk with insurance certificates, leveled written scopes and payments tied to inspections. The sitework version of this discipline is in The Five Sitework Mistakes That Kill Project Budgets.

A five-minute test for your own crew

  1. Pull the last 90 days of payroll hours for one crew.
  2. Divide the hours tied to finished, inspected work by paid hours.
  3. Compute loaded cost per hour from your own books.
  4. Convert your two best sub bids for the same scope into price per labor hour.
  5. Compare your utilization to the break-even from the formula.

Clearing the break-even by ten points means the crew is earning its place. Missing it calls for a smaller crew, a different scope or a sub.

Common questions about self-perform vs subcontract

Is it cheaper to self-perform or subcontract?

Neither is cheaper by default. In-house wins when productive hours exceed the break-even utilization for that trade. With a crew cost of $47 to $52 an hour and sub rates of $65 to $85, the threshold falls between 55 and 80 percent.

What does subcontracting mean?

Subcontracting means hiring an outside firm to perform a defined scope of the work you hold under contract, with that firm paying and directing its own workers.

What is vertical integration in construction, and what is the drawback?

It is a builder performing trades or steps that others usually buy from outside firms. The drawback is fixed payroll: when work slows, in-house crews cost the same.

Is a subcontractor the same as an employee?

No. The IRS looks at three kinds of evidence: behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship. A worker you direct and equip like staff may be an employee whatever the paperwork says, so settle classification with counsel or an accountant.

Is a general contractor liable for a subcontractor's workers' compensation in Michigan?

It can be. Under MCL 418.171, a principal can owe benefits to the employees of a contractor who has not complied with the act. Get a current certificate of insurance before work starts.